Comments on: UM Credit Union Eyes Former News Building

By: Vivienne Armentrout

Vivienne Armentrout — Tue, 27 Apr 2010 14:27:50 +0000

Tricia, could you mean 415 W. Washington? Someone correct me but I think they were hoping that the city would make the property available more or less free.

By: Tricia

Tricia — Tue, 27 Apr 2010 14:25:15 +0000

I agree with Alice – I think it would be great if that building were an arts space. The Art Association was looking to build a project in the property across from the YMCA – I wonder if they could rework this building instead?

By: Joel Goldberg

Joel Goldberg — Tue, 27 Apr 2010 13:09:41 +0000

Although a building that size may look like a stretch for UMCU, it has a track record of acquiring more space than it needs and growing into it. When it built the current building, it rented the extra space to compatible organizations such as the Feminist Federal Credit Union (later absorbed into UMCU) and the Ann Arbor Cooperative Society, and gradually grew to occupy the entire building.

But a bar? Not certain about the simpatico factor…

By: Tom Jones

Tom Jones — Tue, 27 Apr 2010 11:53:52 +0000

Typo Schillag not Schillage, beginning of 7th sentence!

By: Mary Morgan

Mary Morgan — Tue, 27 Apr 2010 02:24:50 +0000

Several years ago I toured the AT&T building – at that time, Ameritech. It actually seemed abandoned, on some floors, with vast empty spaces where the old switching systems used to be housed. There is tight security because the phone system’s trunk lines come into the basement. Because of that, I was told, it’s unlikely the building would be opened for other uses. Quite a waste.

And, of course, I still hold out hope that someone will create a bar called The Pressroom in the portion of the A2 News building that contains the old presses. I have great affection for those inked-up, mechanical hulks.

By: Rod Johnson

Rod Johnson — Tue, 27 Apr 2010 02:02:49 +0000

Thanks for the thoughtful answer. I had sort of forgotten about the old telephone building. As for the bunker–tear it down, sez I. Unsalvageable. No building should turn such a blank face on what should be a signature street.

I’m hoping that the improvements along Division will make the AA News building less oppressive–it’s that narrow space between the traffic and the wall that I dislike. This is a building that works better from a distance than close up, I think. Chacun a son gout.

By: Tom Whitaker

Tom Whitaker — Tue, 27 Apr 2010 00:46:02 +0000

I agree that the modern telephone building on Huron looks like a bunker and the portion of the Ann Arbor News building at Division and Washington could use some windows (it’s where the press is located).

But the original telephone building on Washington (behind the bunker) was designed by William Kapp of Smith, Hinchman and Grylls and is a fine example of the Beaux Arts style. It was built in 1925. Kapp also designed the Rackham School of Graduate Studies a few blocks east of there, Meadowbrook Hall in Rochester Hills, and the Music Hall in Detroit. His firm designed many well known buildings throughout the country, but perhaps are best known locally for the Guardian Building in Detroit.

I’d love to know how much use the old telephone building (or the bunker for that matter) is actually getting these days. I recall that it (and the bunker) were once filled with switchboards and other delicate gear, but perhaps electronics and computers have since decreased the amount of space actively being used. Perhaps the gear could even be moved someplace outside of downtown? It would be great to turn that bunker into a real building for humans and restore the original building on Washington for use as apartments, offices or studios.

Albert Kahn, probably the best known Detroit architect designed the Ann Arbor News building, built in 1936, and I think it’s still a fine looking building–especially viewed from the Huron/Division corner (the original portion that he designed). Walk down the Division street side some time and check out the bas-relief pieces. There’s an old nighttime photo from the 30′s or 40′s where the building looks to be straight out of a film noir drama. I can see a bank use on the Huron side, a retail use on the Washington side, and perhaps office use on the upper floor and west side.

Besides many of our churches, there are precious few iconic buildings in Ann Arbor that are not owned by the University of Michigan. I hope that these two buildings will someday be respectfully rehabilitated so that they can be actively used by their owners and enjoyed by passers-by for many generations to come. They are landmarks of Ann Arbor’s business and industry, from an era when the U of M was not the only entity in town that hired world-class architects.

By: Rod Johnson

Rod Johnson — Mon, 26 Apr 2010 22:56:49 +0000

I agree with Fred. It may have been a marvelous building in its day, but it’s all wrong for the current nature of the site. Between it and the phone company building (what is that called nowadays?), that block contains some of the bleakest stretches of streetscape downtown.

By: Alice Ralph

Alice Ralph — Mon, 26 Apr 2010 21:43:44 +0000

My latest flight of imagination for this marvelous building is use as a civic arts center for Ann Arbor. It is a work of art itself. It’s structure might even accommodate a couple of additional floors. The parking lot could be developed as 8-10 stories of afforadable apartments for cultural producers next to display, work, learning and performance spaces in the remodeled Ann Arbor *Cultural* News Building. Such conversions are happening all over the country. What a great mixing place between town and gown! A credit union or other banking operation will do little to enliven the block. Open the windows to creativity!

By: Anon-U-Are

Anon-U-Are — Mon, 26 Apr 2010 19:28:20 +0000

Hehe.

Looks like you scooped the a2dotcom, er. Ann Arbor News, on its own story.

Keep it up!