Milestone: Why You Keep Running a Marathon

Why it's ok to jump the gun and why it's sometimes ok to quit running

The Chronicle’s monthly milestone column is by custom published on the second day of the month. It’s a chance for us to touch base with readers on topics related to this publication.

My shoes from the Oct. 26, 2003 Marine Corps Marathon in Washington D.C.

My shoes from the Oct. 26, 2003 Marine Corps Marathon in Washington D.C.

It’s not June 2 yet, so today’s publication means we’re jumping the gun a bit. That’s due in part to a selfish, practical interest I have in not writing separate emails to every reader who inquires: Where is your coverage of the Ann Arbor Public Schools? We’ve suspended that coverage for the indefinite future – but obviously not because we don’t think education is important.

When The Chronicle first launched back in 2008, we didn’t offer any coverage of the local public schools. Mostly through sheer good fortune we found independent freelancers – first Jennifer Coffman, and then Monet Tiedemann – who were able to provide coverage of AAPS to Chronicle readers.

It is not easy to find writers who believe that The Chronicle’s approach to coverage – through detailed reports of public meetings – is a worthy endeavor. And among those who believe it’s worth doing, it’s not easy to find writers who can actually meet the standard. And among that smaller group, it’s not easy to find those who are able to reconcile the economics of the compensation we offer with the sacrifice of time and effort.

It is really not easy to find a writer who is willing to sit through a school board meeting that lasts until 3 a.m.

The Chronicle’s publisher and I can absorb a certain amount of flux in available resources, but we’re past capacity. The size of our organization means that when a single person isn’t able to continue in a particular function, it can mean the end of the coverage that person was providing. So for the immediate future, we won’t be able to continue schools coverage.

And for the medium to longer term, I don’t anticipate being able to restore schools coverage unless our revenues through voluntary subscriptions and advertising were to dramatically increase and show evidence of sustaining that increase.

Ultimately, providing sustainable regular coverage of a public body will require more than the good fortune of finding people who, for a while, can wedge The Chronicle into their lives based on the compensation we can offer.

Isn’t some schools coverage better than none at all? Perhaps so. In this column, I’ll lay out my thoughts on that in terms of a metaphor familiar to regular readers of The Chronicle’s milestones: marathon running. [Full Story]

Park Updates: Roof, Rain Garden, Parking Lot

Also, Ann Arbor park commission gets briefed on skatepark construction bids, dog park, downtown parks; elects Galardi as budget chair

Ann Arbor park advisory commission meeting (May 21, 2013): The meeting featured a briefing on a project to install rain gardens at Arbor Oaks Park, part of a broader effort to address drainage and flooding problems in the Bryant neighborhood in southeast Ann Arbor.

Bob Galardi, Ann Arbor park advisory commission, The Ann Arbor Chronicle

Bob Galardi was elected chair of the budget & finance committee for the Ann Arbor park advisory commission at PAC’s May 21, 2013 meeting. (Photos by the writer.)

Jerry Hancock, the city’s stormwater and floodplain programs coordinator, described the project, which is being paid for out of the city’s stormwater utility fund – not the parks and recreation budget. It will involve regrading the perimeter of the park in the fall, then putting in native plants next spring. Soil excavated to create the rain gardens will be used to elevate the park’s central lawn area, which often has standing water following heavy rains. The work will be done prior to improvements planned for the park’s playground next year.

Later in the meeting, commissioners voted to recommend awarding a contract for roof replacement at the Mack indoor pool, located within the Ann Arbor Open school near the corner of Miller and Brooks. The recommendation is to select Pranam GlobalTech Inc., which put in the low bid of $193,000. A 10% construction contingency brings the project’s budget to $212,300, with a portion of that amount to be paid for by the public schools.

Also recommended was using $8,280 from the public market fund to upgrade a surface parking lot – known as the “sand lot” – on the Fourth Avenue side of the farmers market. The paving is viewed as a short-term solution, pending longer-term improvements expected at the market in a few years.

Commissioners also elected Bob Galardi as chair of PAC’s budget & finance committee. He replaces Tim Doyle as committee chair, following the end of Doyle’s term on PAC earlier this month. Jen Geer – Doyle’s replacement on PAC – was confirmed by the city council the previous evening but did not attend PAC’s May 21 meeting. Geer has worked with Galardi and councilmember Christopher Taylor – an ex-officio member of PAC – in another capacity, in the performing arts. Most recently, she was executive producer for the Ann Arbor in Concert production of Ragtime, performed at Michigan Theater on May 18. Both Taylor and Galardi were lead performers in that show.

Updates during PAC’s May 21 meeting covered a range of topics, including news that bids for construction of the new skatepark came in a little higher than anticipated. Parks staff and skatepark designer Wally Hollyday will be reviewing the bids to see what options are available. Parks and recreation manager Colin Smith reported that at PAC’s June 18 meeting, commissioners will be presented with a resolution to award a construction contract, as well as an agreement between the city and the Friends of the Ann Arbor Skatepark related to operating the skatepark.

Other updates from Smith included the fact that parks staff is gearing up for Memorial Day weekend, with the opening of the city’s outdoor pools. He also highlighted the completed renovations of ball fields at Veterans Memorial Park, West Park and Southeast Area Park, and improvements made at Liberty Plaza. In addition to removing some bushes there, he said, “we also removed all sorts of things that were in the bushes, which are no longer there – and I’m glad they’re not.”

Other brief reports were given regarding work of PAC’s dog park and downtown park subcommittees, and public forums for the North Main-Huron River task force. Public commentary focused on input from the Library Green Conservancy, which is advocating for a park or public space atop the city’s Library Lane parking structure. [Full Story]

County Budget, Bonding Decisions Loom

Washtenaw County commissioners get financial update, face $6.99M in cuts, postpone action on major bond proposal until July 10

Washtenaw County board of commissioners meeting (May 15, 2013): A presentation that county commissioners called “daunting” and “sobering” was among several budget-related items on the May 15 agenda.

Young Women Making Washtenaw Better, Washtenaw County sheriff, Washtenaw County board of commissioners, The Ann Arbor Chronicle

From left: Princess Logan and Monique Franklin, students at Ypsilanti High School, are part of the Young Women Making Washtenaw Better program. Seated behind them is Natalia Harris,community outreach coordinator for the Washtenaw County sheriff’s office, which sponsors YWMWB. (Photos by the writer.)

In her state-of-the-county address, county administrator Verna McDaniel set a goal of identifying $6.99 million in structural reductions for the 2014 budget. The approach to addressing this $6.99 million target depends on whether the county moves ahead with a major bond proposal, which would cover the county’s pension and retiree healthcare obligations. [See Chronicle coverage: "County Board Debates $345M Bond Proposal."]

If the board decides not to bond for those obligations, McDaniel said that most of the $6.99 million would need to come from a reduction in operating costs, as well as $100,000 in cuts to outside agency funding. Finding the $6.99 million in cuts would be very challenging, she added, given the amount of reductions that have already occurred in the past few years. Serviceability levels and major programs would be affected.

Action related to the bonding proposal – for up to $345 million, the largest ever issued by the county – was originally on the May 15 agenda. But early in the meeting, board chair Yousef Rabhi announced a decision to push back the process until the board’s July 10 meeting. He cited the need for more time for public input and additional information – including updated actuarial reports that are due in late June. Public hearings on the proposal are set for June 5 and July 10, with a board working session on the issue scheduled for June 6.

The board also voted to hold a special meeting on July 24, to allow for additional bond-related votes and public commentary, if needed. Rabhi also announced a series of informal meetings at coffee shops in Ann Arbor to discuss the bond proposal with residents. The first “Bonding Over Coffee” will be held on Tuesday, May 28 from 4-6 p.m. in the basement of Elixir Vitae (formerly Café Ambrosia) at 326 Maynard St. in Ann Arbor.

Among the several items that the board is expected to vote on at its July 10 meeting is a “notice of intent” to issue the bonds. This is a standard initial step in the bonding process, letting residents know that they have 45 days during which they can circulate petitions to require a vote of the people before any bonds are issued. Ronnie Peterson reminded commissioners that just a few years ago, a citizens group had gathered enough signatures to force another bond proposal – for expansion of the county jail – onto the ballot, where it was defeated by voters. For the current bond proposal, about 15,000 signatures would be required to force a voter referendum.

In another budget-related item on the May 15 agenda, the board received a first-quarter 2013 briefing. The county’s financial staff is now projecting a $818,999 shortfall for the year – the difference between $102,364,815 in projected general fund revenues and $103,183,814 in projected expenditures. That shortfall is lower than the $3.03 million shortfall that was originally projected for 2013.

The board continued its budget discussion at a retreat on May 16, where they worked to hone priorities for the next four years. This Chronicle report includes a summary of that two-hour session.

In other May 15 action, the board gave initial approval to set the 2013 county general operating millage rate at 4.5493 mills – unchanged from the current rate. Several other county millages are levied separately: emergency communications (0.2000 mills), the Huron Clinton Metroparks Authority (0.2146 mills), two for county parks and recreation (0.2353 mills and 0.2367 mills) and for the natural areas preservation program (0.2409 mills). That brings the total county millage rate to 5.6768 mills, a rate that’s also unchanged from 2012. A final vote and public hearing is expected on June 5.

The board also passed a resolution expressing support for the state of Michigan to expand the federal Medicaid program, as part of the Affordable Care Act – a measure currently being debated in the state legislature. During deliberations, Dan Smith (R-District 2) voiced his objection to the county weighing in on state issues, but he left the room prior to the vote.

A range of other issues were raised as items of communication by commissioners or during public commentary. Topics included: (1) a corridor improvement authority planned by Pittsfield Township for a section of State Street; and (2) the possibility of renewing the county’s membership in the Michigan Association of Counties. [Full Story]

May 20, 2013 Ann Arbor Council: In Progress

Main item on the agenda is FY 2014 budget, fees, millage rates. Also: economic development task force; video privacy ordinance; appointments

The main event of the May 20, 2013 Ann Arbor city council meeting will be the council’s approval of the FY 2014 budget. The city’s fiscal year starts July 1. Under terms of the city charter, the council is required to amend and approve the city administrator’s proposed budget by its second meeting in May – which this year falls on May 20. The Chronicle will be filing live updates from city council chambers during the meeting, published “below the fold.”

Door to Ann Arbor city council chambers

Door to the Ann Arbor city council chamber.

If the council fails to act, then the city administrator’s budget, which Steve Powers presented formally to the council on April 15, 2013, would automatically be adopted. It’s been described as essentially a “status quo” budget, with no major changes to personnel levels or basic approaches to service delivery. The council has held work sessions on various aspects of the budget starting in February.

For the general fund, the status quo budget translates to $82,893,312 in total expenditures, which will require tapping the general fund balance for $260,514. That would leave the general fund with $13.8 million in reserves or 17% of operating expenses.

But it’s possible that the council will undertake amendments to that budget. Among the amendments that might be proposed are some that would change the budget of the Ann Arbor Downtown Development Authority. Other amendments that might be put forward provide funding for an increase in the number of police officers. One strategy for increasing funding for police officers is to take money out of the 15th District Court budget. Another strategy that could be brought forward for funding police officers is to re-allocate the salary for retiring assistant city attorney Bob West.

Affordable housing and human services funding will likely be the topic of some amendments. It’s possible to change the budget later in the year, after the May 20 meeting, but that would require an eight-vote majority. Amendments to the main budget resolution of the year – this year on the May 20 agenda – require only a six-vote majority. [Full Story]

Green Light for 413 E. Huron

| At the May 13, 2013 session of a meeting that started on May 6, the Ann Arbor city council began by approving the site plan for 413 E. Huron St. – on a 6-5 vote. Other business at the meeting included a preliminary approval to changes in the city's public art ordinance, as well as wrangling over an appointment to the board of the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority. [Full Story]

Ypsilanti a Topic for AATA Planning Retreat

| At its May 16, 2013 meeting, the board of the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority unanimously passed a resolution acknowledging the city of Ypsilanti's request to join the AATA, when had been made last month. The board also bid farewell to Jesse Bernstein whose term of service ended last month. [Full Story]

County Gives More Support to Rutherford Pool

| At their May 14, 2013 meeting, Washtenaw County parks & rec commissioners voted to grant $150,000 to the city of Ypsilanti to help complete the Rutherford Pool project. The Friends of Rutherford Pool is trying to raise about $1 million to rebuild the community pool, located on the eastern end of Recreation Park at 975 North Congress Street. Commissioners also took steps that will lead to spending over $1.713 million on natural areas preservation of more than 300 acres countywide. [Full Story]

In it for the Money: Independent Risk

| In this month's "In it for the Money" David Erik Nelson describes an activity he spends time on that's guaranteed to earn him no money – maintaining the Workantile coworking space on Main Street in Ann Arbor. "Our business is maintaining a space where a community of independent workers can sit together and work on their own things." [Full Story]

May 13, 2013 Ann Arbor Council: In Progress

| This article includes live updates filed from the May 13, 2013 session of the Ann Arbor city council meeting that started on May 6. The first item to be considered was the site plan for 413 E. Huron. But the agenda included several other items, like a first reading of changes to the public art ordinance. [Full Story]

County Board Wrangles Over Budget Process

| At its May 1, 2013 meeting, the Washtenaw County board of commissioners gave final approval to authorize the development of a four-year budget planning cycle, for the budget starting Jan. 1, 2014. The board also set a budget retreat for May 16, though the location of that retreat – at the county's Learning Resource Center – was debated. Commissioners also heard from residents who are upset about the deteriorating condition of North Territorial Road. [Full Story]

City Council Sets Up for 413 E. Huron

| At its May 6, 2013 meeting, the Ann Arbor city council did not reach the 413 E. Huron site plan on its agenda, but that item will be first to be addressed when the same meeting resumes on May 13. Before recessing the meeting for a week, the council postponed voting on a new video privacy ordinance and revisions to the sign ordinance. Receiving approval from the council was the site plan for Summit Townhomes. [Full Story]

Library OKs Budget, Tax Rate Unchanged

| Reversing a slight tax increase that had been proposed in the draft budget, the Ann Arbor District Library board approved a $12.3 million budget for fiscal 2013-14 with an unchanged tax rate of 1.55 mills. The action took place at the board's May 6, 2013 meeting. The library is authorized to levy up to 1.92 mills, but in recent years has set the millage at a lower rate. [Full Story]

County Board Debates $345M Bond Proposal

| At a May 2, 2013 working session lasting more than 3.5 hours, Washtenaw County commissioners were briefed on a bond proposal to fund the county's pension and retiree healthcare plans, and debated the merits and risks of issuing up to $345 million in bonds – by far the largest issue in the county's history. [Full Story]

May 6, 2013 Ann Arbor Council: In Progress

| This article contains live updates filed from the May 6, 2013 meeting of the Ann Arbor city council. It was expected to last long enough that it would need to be recessed, to be resumed on May 13. Items on the agenda included the site plan for 413 E. Huron St. as well as revisions to the ordinance governing the Ann Arbor Downtown Development Authority. [Full Story]

Greenbelt Commission Seeks New Members

| At the May 2, 2013 meeting of the Ann Arbor greenbelt advisory commission, Stephanie Buttrey – who's being nominated to serve out the remainder of Liz Rother’s term through June 30, 2014 – introduced herself to commissioners. GAC also voted to recommend that the city proceed with the purchase of development rights on two properties, including one in Ann Arbor Township. [Full Story]

Sunday Funnies: Bezonki

| In the May 2013 adventures of Bezonki, our scaly green friend tries some experiments that, not surprisingly, go dangerously awry. He takes advantage of a friend, finds redemption, sells some colored eggs, and in the end, finally gets some rest. Just another month of comic mania! [Full Story]

DDA Parking Trends Continue

| The May 1, 2013 meeting of the Ann Arbor Downtown Development Authority board was brief, consisting of a range of updates and public commentary. This meeting report includes the monthly parking data for March 2013, the most recent month for which it's available. [Full Story]

AAPS Trustees Get Draft FY 2013-14 Budget

| At the April 24 meeting of the Ann Arbor Public School board of education, trustees were presented with a draft budget for FY 2013-14 that calls for roughly $8.7 million in cuts. They also made some decisions related to the search for a new superintendent, setting a salary range of $180,000-220,000. And the board settled on its new committee assignments. [Full Story]

Column: UM Football Policy A Bad Bet

| Changes in the University of Michigan's football ticket policy for students – including raised prices and general admission seating – doesn't get at the root problem of apathy toward the game. Columnist John U. Bacon explains why today's big-money approach to Michigan football is shortchanging students and undercutting long-term loyalty. [Full Story]

Ypsi Waits at Bus Stop, Other Riders Unclear

| Two recent meetings of communities that are part of the "urban core" near Ann Arbor have developed some quiet momentum toward possible improvements in public transportation service in the area. Out of the meetings has come a request by the city of Ypsilanti to join the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority. [Full Story]

Milestone: Relays Without Batons

| In this month's milestone column, Chronicle editor Dave Askins returns to a familiar metaphor for this publication: running. He asks readers to think of themselves as spectators on the route of a running race. What's needed are cheers or drinks of water, not advice on running form. [Full Story]

In the Archives: Last Train to Carp-ville

| In this month's "In the Archives" column local history writer Laura Bien provides a kind of companion piece for an earlier column she wrote on the sturgeon. This one traces the history from the late 1800s of the carp – which was introduced from Germany. One of the characters in the story is a 1901 graduate of the University of Michigan who lived at 703 Church St. [Full Story]

Public Art Group Faces “Interesting Times”

| At its April 24, 2013 meeting, the Ann Arbor public art commission voted to change the submission date of its annual public art plan to the city council, making it synch more closely with the process of developing the city's capital improvements plan (CIP). The change is linked to a major restructuring of the city's public art program. Commissioners also approved a memo to council recommending adding two student commissioners to the nine-member body. [Full Story]

Parks Group Applauds “Status Quo” Budget

| At their April 16, 2013 meeting, Ann Arbor park advisory commissioners were briefed on budget details for FY 2014 and voted unanimously to recommend the budget for approval. It's the first time in several years that no cuts are being made. Also endorsed was a new contract for beverage concessions with Coke – replacing Pepsi – and a $535,000 contract to Pranam Global Tech Inc. to replace the nearly 40-year-old roof at Veterans Memorial Park Ice Arena. Commissioners also were briefed on an increase in graffiti in the parks. [Full Story]

Column: Happy Birthday, Jim Toy

| This brief column was prompted by a mayoral proclamation made at the Ann Arbor city council's April 15, 2013 meeting – which honored Jim Toy's long-time advocacy for LGBT issues. April 29, 2013 is Toy's birthday, which was proclaimed Jim Toy Day. The column contains primarily Toy's remarks made at the council meeting. [Full Story]

Planning Commission Signs Off on R4C Draft

| At their April 16, 2013 meeting, Ann Arbor planning commissioners have recommended approval of changes to the city’s R4C/R2A residential zoning districts, which will now head to city council. At a retreat the following week, commissioners raised concerns about how the progress of implementing R4C changes might be held back by the ongoing ZORO (zoning ordinance reorganization) project, which seems to be languishing in the city attorney's office. [Full Story]

Column: The Best Worst Job of All

| Columnist John U. Bacon takes issue with a recent ranking of careers, which puts the profession of journalism at the bottom of the list. While it's true that the job can be stressful and the newspaper industry is faltering, there are many reasons to love being a journalist, he writes. [Full Story]

Late-Night Bitter Politics Set Stage for May 6

| What did and didn't happen at the Ann Arbor city council's April 15, 2013 meeting? It lasted until after 3 a.m. due to extended remarks from about 100 members of the public. During deliberations on changes to the ordinance governing the Ann Arbor Downtown Development Authority, the council postponed all remaining items on its agenda, including the 413 E. Huron site plan. Even so, the council took votes on a half dozen items, which are included in this report, along with the blow-by-blow deliberations on the DDA. [Full Story]

AAPS Begins Superintendent Search

| At the April 17, 2013 study session of the Ann Arbor Public School board, trustees charted out their process for selecting a replacement for outgoing superintendent Patricia Green. They anticipate doing a fast search, and hope to have a new superintendent in place to start the 2013-14 school year in the fall. They expect an internal candidate to fill the interim position for a relatively short term. [Full Story]

Property Values Up, Budget Decisions Loom

| Major budget issues were the focus of the April 17, 2013 Washtenaw County board of commissioners meeting, including news that tax revenues in 2013 will be higher than anticipated, based on the annual equalization report. The board also gave initial approval to a four-year budget planning cycle, and received material related to a significant bond proposal that they'll be briefed on during a May 2 working session. Commissioners also voted to officially dissolve the Washtenaw Ride, a countywide transit authority. [Full Story]

Public Art Commission Seeks Student Input

| At its March 27, 2013 meeting, Ann Arbor public art commission considered a proposal to add slots for high school and college students on the commission. AAPAC voted to forward this recommendation to the city council. This Chronicle report also includes an update on the city council committee that's currently revising the city's public art ordinance. The committee expects to present its recommendations to the full council on May 6. [Full Story]

AirRide Talks OK’d, Ypsilanti to Join AATA?

| At its April 18, 2013 meeting, the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority board authorized negotiations for the second year of a contract with Michigan Flyer to continue to provide bus service between downtown Ann Arbor and Detroit Metropolitan Airport. The AATA also bid farewell to David Nacht, who'd served two 5-year terms on the board. Non-voting items on the board's agenda included discussion of regional issues, including the possibility that the city of Ypsilanti might join the AATA. [Full Story]

Column: Literati’s “Moment on the Page”

| Columnist Domenica Trevor reflects on the recent opening of Literati Bookstore in downtown Ann Arbor. The owners are investing time and money, she writes, and the community has an obligation to do more than jut sing their praises for it. They are not going to succeed unless lots of people spend money there too – and often. [Full Story]

Smaller Deficit to Inform AAPS Budget Talks

| At their April 10, 2013 meeting Ann Arbor Public Schools trustees heard a new forecast for the anticipated deficit for the FY 2013-14 year. The new forecast puts that figure at just under $9 million, which is significantly less than the $17 million shortfall initially projected. The board also decided to eliminate its committee-of-the-whole, in favor of two standing committees – which is a return to prior practice. The board also voted to impose time limits on meetings. [Full Story]