The Ann Arbor Chronicle masthead
it's like being there

Column: Two-Year Milestone

Some thoughts on preserving journalism and The Chronicle

Editor’s Note: The monthly milestone column, which appears on the second day of each month – the anniversary of The Ann Arbor Chronicle’s launch – is an opportunity for either the publisher or the editor of The Chronicle to touch base with readers on topics related to this publication.

Letter from The Ann Arbor Chronicle to the Ann Arbor District Library

Letter from The Ann Arbor Chronicle to the Ann Arbor District Library.

Last month I trekked over to the Ann Arbor District Library to hand-deliver a paper document to the library’s director, Josie Parker. It was a letter that stated our intent, as owners of The Ann Arbor Chronicle, to grant all necessary legal authority to the AADL to preserve public access to our publication’s archives, in the event that The Chronicle closes or that we get hit by a bus.

It was an important decision for us, and one we didn’t take lightly – “we” being me and my husband Dave Askins, who’s editor and co-owner of The Chronicle. For me, The Chronicle has always been a convergence of the professional and the personal. Launching the publication on Sept. 2, which is also our wedding anniversary, reflects that connection. So choosing how to ensure the preservation of The Chronicle’s archives was more than a business decision.

The corpus of civic affairs and local government reporting that we’ve compiled in The Chronicle’s first two years, we believe, is a community asset worth preserving. During my tenure at The Ann Arbor News, I was always appalled at the condition of the archives there, neglected and deteriorating in a basement space we called The Cage. I was thrilled when the AADL negotiated to become caretaker of that massive collection, some items dating back to the late 1800s. Given the AADL staff’s obvious competence and eagerness to dig into the project – organizing more than 1 million items – it seemed a natural fit to ask that they consider shepherding our much less space-demanding slice of local journalism, too.

The Chronicle, of course, was born digital, and at this point would fit on a thumb drive. Although we’d likely be classified by most folks as “new media,” in many ways we embrace an ethos that runs contrary to current trends. And that’s why I liked the idea of walking a few blocks to the library and handing over a letter – a physical artifact that outlines the hopes of a digital future. And on this occasion of The Chronicle’s second anniversary, I’d like to chew on that notion a little more, and talk about what its implications might be. [Full Story]

Laws of Physics II: Homeless Encampment

MISSION now a nonprofit, goal of land sponsor more realistic

Exactly one year ago, on Sept. 1, 2009, the homeless community that had been camping behind Arborland mall was evicted from that location by Ann Arbor police officers. So the residents of Camp Take Notice, a self-governed community of homeless people, spent that first night of September just north of the park-and-ride lot at Ann Arbor-Saline Road and I-94.

welcome-to-camp-take-notice

Signs on the trail to Camp Take Notice. (Photos by the writer)

Last year, The Chronicle reported the commentary on those events from Ellen Schulmeister, executive director of the Shelter Association of Washtenaw County: “It’s simple physics,” she said. “People have to be some place, and if people don’t have a place to be, they will find a place to be.”

The state police paid a visit, taking names but making no arrests. Later one of the campers, Caleb Poirier, would be arrested on charges of trespassing on the Michigan Dept. of Transportation property. Poirier was represented by David Blanchard of the law firm Nacht & Associates, P.C. The ACLU filed an amicus brief in support of Poirier, and the charges against the camper were eventually dropped. The camp’s current location is off Wagner Road near I-94.

In the course of the past year, members of the community – some homeless campers, some not – who organized in support of the tent encampment under the name Michigan Itinerant Shelter System Interdependent Out of Necessity (MISSION) have achieved more than simply a successful legal defense of one of their members. They were a key force in prompting the city of Ann Arbor and Washtenaw County to consider allocating emergency shelter funds for the winter of 2009-10.

And their recent achievement of official nonprofit status as a 501(c)(3) organization means that the goal of finding land sponsors to host the camp legally appears a bit more realistic. A student with the University of Michigan Law School who’s working with MISSION has sketched out a model for how liabilities could be handled by defining appropriate relationships among the land sponsor, MISSION and the homeless camp. The group heard a presentation on legal issues last Friday morning at the Washtenaw County Annex on Fourth Avenue.

But it’s all still a matter of physical laws. UM physics doctoral student Brian Nord, who’s president of MISSION’s board, compares Camp Take Notice to a gas and MISSION to a relief valve: “As long as the environment within camp is positive and community-driven, the methods of CTN can be fluid and operate as a gas. However, the established societal regulations and more so the prejudices act as a maximal container of this fluid. MISSION, the valve, has to evolve itself to consistently advocate for the rights of the individual, while appearing as part of the establishment to the camp.”

As The Chronicle noted a year ago, “This is a story that does not yet have an end, nor will it likely ever have one.” But it is now time for an update. [Full Story]

Recounting the Rabhi-Fried Recount

Would you like what's in Box 1 or in Box 2?

Last Thursday, a hand recount of ballots was conducted in the District 11 Democratic primary election for Washtenaw County commissioner. Initial results from the Aug 3. election had yielded Yousef Rabhi as the winner in a field of four candidates – by one vote. The candidate with 997 votes counted on election day, compared to Rabhi’s 998, was Mike Fried, who asked that the ballots be recounted.

Alice Ralph Jan BenDor Conan Smith Mike Fried

Before the Aug. 26 recounting got started, Conan Smith (left), a current county commissioner acting as one of Youself Rabhi's official "watchers," chats with Mike Fried (right), who'd asked for the recount. Shooting video for the Michigan Election Reform Alliance was Jan BenDor. Seated in the background is Alice Ralph, who came third in the balloting for the District 11 seat.

The process started around 12:30 p.m., and about four hours later in the lower level conference room of the county building at 200 N. Main St., the final ballots had been recounted – the last ones coming from Precinct 2 in Ann Arbor Township. [District 11 covers parts of southeast Ann Arbor and one precinct in Ann Arbor Township.]

Fried summed up the afternoon, conceding to Rabhi – who was still the winner after the recounting, with a relatively comfortable margin of two votes: “Well, congratulations!”

Fried continued with compliments all around for  the board of canvassers and the election inspectors who handled the recounting, saying he was amazed that they had finished in four hours.

The board of canvassers consists of Tony DeMott (R), Melodie Gable (R), Ulla Roth (D), and Carol Kuhnke (D). The news was first reported by The Ann Arbor Chronicle live from the scene: “Rabhi Prevails on Recount.”

The work might have been completed sooner, had it not been for a snafu with the Ann Arbor Township ballot box. Initially, the box for Precinct 1, not Precinct 2, had been delivered for recounting. Getting access to the correct box depended on tracking down someone with a key to the room in the township clerk’s office, where the ballots are stored.

Recounted totals for the four candidates: Yousef Rabhi, 999; Mike Fried, 997; Alice Ralph, 280; LuAnne Bullington, 108.

The afternoon included a range of scenarios that illuminated some of the more arcane aspects of the voting system. Also in attendance was Joe Baublis, who will be on the ballot for the Republicans in November for the District 11 county board seat. He posed a question at the start of the proceedings: How much will this recount cost taxpayers? [Full Story]

Know Your Kirk: Public Servant

Kirk Westphal serves on planning, environmental commissions

About six years ago, Kirk Westphal was living in New York City with his wife, Cynthia. So it’s a fair question to ask: “How did you get here?” Sitting in one of the cozy lounge chairs in the the Espresso Royale on Main Street, Wesphal talked about how he gets to places like the café, how he came to his current line of work, and how he made his serendipitous move to Ann Arbor.

Kirk Westphal seems to recognize the guy on his video-editing screen. (Chronicle file photo, June 2010.)

“[My wife and I] were on a run in Central Park one night and we thought, we love New York but we’d be open to going someplace else,” Westphal recalls. When asked by his wife where he would want to move, Westphal’s automatic response was one that surprised her: Ann Arbor. “Her jaw went to the floor, ‘cause she didn’t think I knew anything about Michigan,” Westphal says, “which I didn’t.” The next day, Westphal’s wife searched online for jobs at the University of Michigan, and found an open faculty position at the School of Music. “One thing lead to another and she got that job,” Westphal says. “It was a message.”

Though Westphal may be a recent “import from New York,” he has already accumulated a range of community service experience in his six years here in Ann Arbor. Westphal serves as vice chair of the city’s planning commission, having been a member for four years, and also holds a spot on the environmental commission. He’s also serving on the design guidelines task force that is working on the final piece of the recent rezoning of downtown, known as A2D2. [Full Story]

Column: This Empty Nester Loves Skype

August 29 | Columnist Jo Mathis describes her newfound love of Skype, a video chat application that helps her stay in touch with family and friends. [Full Story]

School Board Issues RFP for Search Firm

August 27 | At a special meeting held Aug. 23, 2010, the Ann Arbor Public Schools board voted to issue a request for proposals for search firms to aid with the hiring of a new superintendent. [Full Story]

Column: Hemingway’s Michigan

August 27 | Columnist John U. Bacon takes a summer vacation to northern Michigan, and reflects on how the region held special meaning for the writer Ernest Hemingway. [Full Story]

DDA Parking Enforcement Prospects Dim

August 24 | At their second meeting of the month, held on Aug. 23, the respective mutually beneficial committees of the city of Ann Arbor and the Downtown Development Authority pushed parking enforcement by the DDA to the edge, but not completely off the table. Their work plan for the summer calls for them to tackle the topic of the DDA's role in development of city-owned surface parking lots. The next meeting takes place on Sept. 13. [Full Story]

AAPS Special Meeting Time Changed

August 23 | The AAPS school board changed a meeting previously scheduled for Tuesday, Aug. 24 to Monday, 6:30 p.m. at the Balas administration building. The purpose of the meeting is to review a request for proposals (RFP) for a search firm that will assist in the hiring of a new superintendent. [Full Story]

Column: Seeds & Stems

August 22 | Columnist Marianne Rzepka writes that after years of watching emerald ash borers decimate thousands of once-thriving ash trees, Ann Arbor residents can find a new generation of the hardwoods growing in some of the wooded pockets of the city. [Full Story]

Column: Take Me Out to the Minor Leagues

August 20 | Looking for some end-of-summer entertainment? Columnist John U. Bacon suggests checking out a minor league baseball game. The minors know how to have fun, and treat their fans royally. [Full Story]

Public Turns Out to Support Huron Hills Golf

August 19 | The Ann Arbor Parks Advisory Commission spent most of its Aug. 17, 2010 meeting discussing a draft of a request for proposals (RFP) for Huron Hills Golf Course. About 30 members of the public showed up for the meeting, many of them speaking against the RFP. [Full Story]

Shoring Up the Ann Arbor Senior Center

August 16 | The Chronicle gets an update on efforts to raise revenues and decrease costs at the Ann Arbor Senior Center, which was at risk of closing due to city budget cuts. [Full Story]

Hate Crime Rhetoric Not Supported by Facts

August 15 | The Chronicle follows up on an incident last year that at the time was characterized by some as a hate crime against an Arab-American girl. The girl has recently been found guilty of disorderly conduct – witnesses say she was, in fact, an instigator of a fight with an African-American girl. Both were students at Skyline High School at the time. [Full Story]

Funding Set for More Art at Municipal Center

August 14 | At their Aug. 10, 2010 meeting, the Ann Arbor Public Art Commission voted down a third proposed art installation by the German artist Herbert Dreiseitl, intended for the lobby of the municipal center's new police/courts building. They had rejected another proposed interior work at last month's meeting, but a project of his that was approved – an outdoor water sculpture – is moving ahead. Also, AAPAC budgeted an additional $250,000 for other public art in the center, to be selected by a task force. [Full Story]

Column: In the Ring

August 13 | Sports columnist John U. Bacon examines the ethics and art of bullfighting. Done well, the sport takes courage and skill, he writes. [Full Story]

In the Archives: Two Worlds

August 12 | This week, local history columnist Laura Bien takes a look back to the era when assimilation of Native Americans to the non-native culture was considered progressive. [Full Story]

Modified Moratorium on Marijuana Passed

August 8 | At its Aug. 5, 2010 meeting, the Ann Arbor city council passed a 120-day moratorium on dispensing and cultivating marijuana. A large audience had shown up to express opposition to the moratorium. Amendments at the table weakened the force of the measure considerably from the one originally proposed by city attorney Stephen Postema. The council also approved Zaragon Place 2, and a purchase option agreement for Village Green for the First and Washington parcel. The council also advanced a porch couch ban to a second reading. [Full Story]

Column: Arbor Vinous

August 7 | Wine columnist Joel Goldberg takes an in-depth look at laws governing BYOB, and finds some surprises for those interested in taking a bottle from their own wine cellar to their favorite restaurant. [Full Story]

Column: Book Fare

August 28 | Domenica Trevor, The Chronicle's book columnist, takes a look at some of the books that have helped her through the last 12 months – and that other readers might enjoy, too. [Full Story]

In The Archives: Bonnet-Starching Tips

August 27 | Local history columnist Laura Bien describes a soggy experience reenacting the role of an anonymous scrubwoman at the Ypsilanti Heritage Festival, held Aug. 20-22. [Full Story]

Urban County Reallocates Housing Funds

August 25 | At its Aug. 24, 2010 meeting, the Washtenaw Urban County executive committee approved reallocating funds from the federal Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP), and selected SOS Community Services as the go-to agency for managing housing crises in the county. [Full Story]

Planning Commission Bylaws Tweaked

August 24 | At their Aug. 17, 2010 meeting, the Ann Arbor planning commission reviewed and approved revised bylaws. Two proposed rezoning items on the agenda – for Arbor Hills Nature Area and Kilburn Park – were postponed. [Full Story]

Firm to Aid Schools in Superintendent Search

August 23 | In its main business of the Aug. 18, 2010 meeting, the Ann Arbor Public Schools board of trustees reached a consensus that they would hire a search firm to help with the selection process for a superintendent to replace Todd Roberts, who recently announced his resignation. [Full Story]

Four-Year Trail to Non-Motorized Path

August 20 | At its Aug. 16, 2010 meeting, the Ann Arbor city council passed the third of four resolutions necessary to effect a special assessment for property owners along Washtenaw Avenue to provide a small portion of the funding for a non-motorized path that will be constructed there. The council also handled a variety of easements and heard three mayoral proclamations in an unusually short meeting. [Full Story]

AATA Board Fails to Achieve Quorum

August 20 | Attendance by only three of the seven Ann Arbor Transportation Authority board members at the Aug. 19, 2010 meeting meant that no meeting took place on pain of a failure to achieve a quorum. Board chair Jesse Bernstein extended his apologies to AATA staff and the public who attended. [Full Story]

Know Your AATA Board: Roger Kerson

August 17 | The Chronicle sat down and talked with Roger Kerson, the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority board's newest member. He was fresh off a four-hour long board retreat, held at Weber's Inn on Aug. 10, when the board discussed a number of strategic initiatives. [Full Story]

AATA Targets Specific Short-Term Strategies

August 15 | At a four-hour special meeting on Aug. 10, 2010, the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority board considered several resolutions outlining the organization's strategy for a variety of different challenges, including: Ann Arbor-Ypsilanti service, Ann Arbor-Canton service, service to the Detroit airport, north-south commuter rail (WALLY), and van pool services. [Full Story]

With Roberts’ Exit, AAPS Plans Next Steps

August 14 | With the announced departure of superintendent Todd Roberts on Friday Aug. 13, the AAPS school board will put together a plan for replacement at a meeting on Wed., Aug 18. [Full Story]

Ann Arbor Schools Superintendent Resigns

August 13 | Todd Roberts, who has served as superintendent of the Ann Arbor Public Schools for four years, announced his resignation today in an email sent to school staff. He cited personal reasons, and is returning to North Carolina to take a job as chancellor of the North Carolina School of Science and Math, based in Durham. [Full Story]

Library Board Candidates Meet with Staff

August 12 | At an Aug. 11, 2010 information session for Ann Arbor District Library board candidates, four of the seven people whose names will be on the Nov. 2 ballot talked with library staff about a range of issues, from library millage rates to the changing role of the library in society. [Full Story]

Health Care Impacts County’s Bottom Line

August 10 | At their Aug. 5, 2010 working session, the Washtenaw County board of commissioners got an update on health care benefit costs and on the potential impact of recent federal health care legislation. [Full Story]

No More “Felony Box” on County Job Forms

August 8 | At its Aug. 4, 2010 meeting, the Washtenaw County board of commissioners approved eliminating the so-called "felony box" from county job applications. After some debate, background checks will continue for all applicants who receive a conditional job offer. The board also approved brownfield plans for Zingerman's Deli and the Near North housing project, but tabled action on re-establishing a land bank. [Full Story]

Payments, Permits in Lieu of Parking

August 5 | At their July 20, 2010 meeting, the Ann Arbor planning commission was briefed about a payment-in-lieu-of-parking (PILOP) program that's being proposed by the Ann Arbor Downtown Development Authority. [Full Story]

» Text size:

larger text default text smaller text

Skyclock